New At Apple Creek- Cooper Sharp
Iconic Pennsylvanian Cheese since 1893! Cooper Sharp is a Sharp White American Cheese. This cheese melts incredibly well and is delicious on Philly Cheesesteaks. This cheese is quickly becoming a popular item here at Apple Creek! Come try it out for yourself!
Stop by today to try our famous Amish Butter Cheese!
Employee Favorites
Yellow Amish Butter Cheese
Muenster
Horseradish Cheddar
Green Onion
Blueberry Cheddar
Mediterranean Sunset
Garlic Cheese
Hot Pepper
Desert Fire
Smoked Swiss
Cooper Sharp
Lactose Free Cheeses
White Amish Butter Cheese
Farmer’s
Farmer’s Garden Vegetable
Our Mediterranean Cheddar has a blend of Italian herbs, spices, and sundried tomatoes! It tastes like a pizza!
Are you brave enough to try our spicy cheeses?
Try our customer favorite Desert Fire Cheese! It tastes good on practically anything!
Deli Cheeses
Traditional
Colby
Marble
American Yellow
White American
Cooper Sharp American
Yellow Amish Butter Cheese
White Amish Butter Cheese
Muenster
Provolone
Farmer’s
Colby Swiss Swirl
Cheddar
Cheddar
Sharp Cheddar
X-Sharp Cheddar
Mediterranean Sunset
Horseradish Cheddar
Sharp White Cheddar
Specialty
Farmer’s Garden Vegetable
Green Onion
Bacon
Garlic Cheese
Horseradish American
Havarti
Havarti Dill
Havarti Herbs & Spices
Blue Marble
Bruschetta Jack
Blueberry Cheddar
Swiss
Swiss Cuts
Guggisberg Baby Swiss
Lacey Baby Swiss
Aged Swiss
Swiss n Rye
Smoked
Smoked Swiss
Smoked Bacon
Smoked Provolone
Smoked Hot Pepper
Smoked Horseradish Cheddar
Smoked Green Onion
Smoked Gouda
Smoked Habanero Jalapeno
Hot Cheese
Hot Pepper
Pepper Jack
Habanero Cheddar
Muenster Jalapeno
Desert Fire
Mango Fire
Lightning Jack
Ghost Pepper
Scorpion Pepper
Carolina Reaper